‘It’s a monster’: How generative AI is forcing university professors to rethink learning


In a dimly lit, traditional university lecture hall, a monstrous, multi-limbed, glowing blue digital creature with glowing red eyes looms large behind a professor at a podium. Around tables in the foreground, other professors in academic robes express concern and confusion, some pointing at the creature, while a blackboard in the background reads "RETHINK CURRICULUM" and "HUMAN PROMPT." Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.
Described by some as a “monster,” generative AI is fundamentally challenging established educational paradigms. This image dramatically illustrates the immense, even intimidating, presence of AI in academia, compelling university professors to urgently rethink and innovate their approaches to learning and curriculum design. Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.

Source

The Irish Times

Summary

Professors in Ireland are rethinking what learning and assessment mean as generative AI becomes widespread. With students using tools like ChatGPT for brainstorming, summarisation, and essay writing, faculty are concerned not just about plagiarism but about diminished reflection, reading, and originality. Responses include replacing take‑home essays with in‑class/open‑book work, designing reflective and relational assignments, and rebuilding community in learning. Faculty warn education is becoming transactional, focused on grades over growth, and AI use may hollow out critical thinking unless institutions redesign pedagogy and policies.

Key Points

  • Widespread AI use by students undermines traditional essays and originality.
  • Professors replace take‑home essays with in‑class/open‑book assessments.
  • Assignments now stress reflection, relational thinking, vulnerability — areas AI struggles with.
  • Students under pressure turn to AI instrumentally, prioritising grades over growth.
  • Institutions face resource challenges in redesigning assessments and policies.

Keywords

URL

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/education/2025/09/09/its-a-monster-how-generative-ai-is-forcing-university-professors-to-rethink-learning/

Summary generated by ChatGPT 5