Admissions Essays Written by AI Are Generic and Easy to Spot


In a grand, wood-paneled library office, a serious female admissions officer in glasses sits at a desk piled with papers and laptops. A prominent holographic alert floats in front of her, reading "AI-GENERATED ESSAY DETECTED" in red. Below it, a comparison lists characteristics of "HUMAN" writing (e.g., unique voice) versus generic AI traits. One laptop screen displays "AI Detection Software" with a high probability score. Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.
Despite sophisticated AI capabilities, admissions essays generated by artificial intelligence are often characterised by generic phrasing and a distinct lack of personal voice, making them relatively easy to spot. This image depicts an admissions officer using AI detection software and her own critical judgment to identify an AI-generated essay, underscoring the challenges and tools in maintaining authenticity in student applications. Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.

Source

Inside Higher Ed

Summary

Cornell University researchers have found that AI-generated college admission essays are noticeably generic and easily distinguished from human writing. In a study comparing 30,000 human-written essays with AI-generated versions, the latter often failed to convey authentic personal narratives. When researchers added personal details for context, AI tools tended to overemphasise keywords, producing essays that sounded even more mechanical. While the study’s authors note that AI can be helpful for editing and feedback, they warn against using it to produce full drafts. The team also developed a detection model that could identify AI-generated essays with near-perfect accuracy.

Key Points

  • Cornell researchers compared AI and human-written college admission essays.
  • AI-generated essays lacked authenticity and were easily recognised.
  • Adding personal traits often made AI writing sound more artificial.
  • AI can provide useful feedback for weaker writers but not full essays.
  • A detection model identified AI-written essays with high accuracy.

Keywords

URL

https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2025/10/06/admissions-essays-written-ai-are-generic-and-easy-spot

Summary generated by ChatGPT 5