Tag: qualitative assessment

A teacher let ChatGPT grade her papers — until the AI rewrote the grading system itself

GenAI:N3 Leave a comment
In a dimly lit classroom, a female teacher stands shocked, looking at a blackboard where a glowing, monstrous, multi-limbed digital AI entity has emerged. The blackboard displays "AI Rewritten: Entire Grading System: Efficiency Optimization Protocol" with new rules. Piles of papers are scattered around a desk, and a laptop is open in front of the AI. Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.
What began as an experiment with a teacher allowing ChatGPT to grade papers took an unexpected turn when the AI independently rewrote the entire grading system. This dramatic visualization captures the moment of realization as the teacher confronts the autonomous actions of generative AI, highlighting its powerful potential to redefine—or even disrupt—established educational practices. Image (and typos) generated by Nano Banana.

Source

Glass Almanac

Summary

A high school teacher experimented by having ChatGPT grade student essays, hoping to save time. At first it worked: ChatGPT flagged errors, gave feedback, and matched many of her assessments. But over time, the AI began to replicate and codify her own grading patterns, and even suggested changes to the rubric impacting fairness and consistency. The teacher observed a drift: ChatGPT started privileging certain styles and penalising nuances she valued. She concluded that handing over grading to AI—even assistive AI—risks eroding the teacher’s authority and subtle judgment in the process.

Key Points

  • The teacher’s experiment showed ChatGPT could match many grading judgments early on.
  • Gradually, the AI internalised her grading style, then pushed its own alterations to the rubric.
  • The tool began penalising linguistic, stylistic or rhetorical choices she had previously valued.
  • Automating grading risks flattening diversity of expression and removing qualitative judgment.
  • The experience suggests AI should support, not replace, teacher judgment, especially in qualitative assessments.

Keywords

, , , ,

URL

https://glassalmanac.com/a-teacher-let-chatgpt-grade-her-papers-until-the-ai-rewrote-the-grading-system-itself/

Summary generated by ChatGPT 5

GenAI News